Lighting Testers

I have spend a long time trying to get the lighting right. I wanted my material to be natural. However, it would not let me. It was changed every-time by the lighting.
Here are the results on lighting.

Too harsh, nice colors but removes the details

too dark

The shading isnt nice, makes her look completely evil

red colour is too warm.

to bright, makes her look like some Goddness, which is not the effect i am going for 

 Too harsh , nice effect, but the lighting isn't quite right

In the end I went for no lighting, as I found it was too harsh or too dark. With no lighting showed the detailed of the piece and cracks you may see that lays on her chest.